Talk with STEP

The Learning Objective Should Decide Whether AI Belongs

Should students be allowed to use AI on an assignment?

Without knowing the assignment, the student, and the learning objective, that question is almost impossible to answer well.

Consider writing

If students are learning to construct an argument, asking AI to create the argument removes much of the learning.

But AI might be useful later.

Students could ask it to challenge their reasoning, identify a counterargument, or comment on clarity.

Same technology.

Different role.

Consider research

AI can help students explore unfamiliar topics, generate questions, or identify possible directions.

But students still need to distinguish evidence from assertion, evaluate sources, verify important claims, and determine what is credible.

Consider problem solving

If the learning objective is mastering the process required to solve a certain problem, having AI solve it defeats the purpose.

If students already possess that capability and are applying it inside a much larger project, AI assistance may allow them to tackle something more ambitious.

Replace the universal rule with a useful question

Instead of:

Do we allow AI?

Ask:

Should AI do this part of the work, for this student, in this activity, given what we want the student to learn?

That question acknowledges something educators already know.

Context matters.

Start with what matters

AI policies are useful.

Guidelines are useful.

Technology controls can be useful.

But none can substitute for clearly understanding what students are supposed to learn.

The learning objective should come first.

Then we decide where technology belongs.

What should AI readiness look like at your school?

Every school starts from a different place. STEP works with educators to understand what students need, where AI can appropriately extend their capabilities, and how the school can evaluate whether its approach is actually working.

Complimentary School + AI Readiness Session with Brian Pinkus, Founder